A Brother Who Sins

January 16, 2026

Theological Summary

Key insights and takeaways from the text.

Matthew 18:15-20 provides a profound framework for maintaining holiness, reconciliation, and unity within the Christian community, revealing key aspects of God's character and His empowering of the church. The passage begins by outlining a multi-step process for addressing sin within the fellowship, emphasizing restoration over condemnation. The central message here is that when a brother or sister sins, the primary goal is to win them back to fellowship and righteousness. This process starts with a private conversation, then involves one or two witnesses, and finally, if necessary, brings the matter before the entire church. This highlights God's desire for personal responsibility, accountability, and the painstaking effort He expects His people to undertake to secure the repentance and restoration of an erring member. The instruction to 'treat them as you would a pagan or a tax collector' is not an endorsement of hatred or abandonment, but rather a somber recognition of a break in covenant relationship, signaling a need for a renewed call to repentance from an external perspective, much as Jesus ministered to outsiders. This entire process underscores the theological concept of sanctification – the ongoing purification and setting apart of God's people for His purposes – and the deep value God places on the integrity and spiritual health of His church. It also speaks to our identity in Christ, calling us to love one another with a restorative, rather than punitive, heart. Practically, it means Christians are called to courageous, loving confrontation, rejecting gossip and passive avoidance, and actively pursuing reconciliation and holiness within the body of Christ. It reflects God's character as one who desires reconciliation, justice, and the holiness of His people.The passage then transitions to the profound authority given to the church in verse 18: 'whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.' This echoes the authority given to Peter in Matthew 16:19, but here it is extended to the gathered community of believers. This isn't a carte blanche for arbitrary decisions, but rather a declaration that when the church, guided by the Holy Spirit and biblical principles, makes decisions concerning discipline, doctrine, and moral issues – particularly in the context of addressing sin as described in the preceding verses – those decisions have divine backing and heavenly validation. It speaks to the incredible responsibility and spiritual power entrusted to the collective body of believers to discern and declare God's will on earth. This concept of 'binding and loosing' signifies the church's authority to prohibit or permit certain practices or teachings based on biblical truth, effectively functioning as God's ambassadors in applying His kingdom principles on earth. This points to a God who actively involves and empowers His church in His ongoing redemptive work, affirming that He stands behind the faithful and prayerful declarations of His people.Finally, verses 19-20 offer immense comfort and reassurance, particularly in the context of the gravity of church discipline and discernment. 'If two of you on earth agree about anything they ask for, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven. For where two or three gather in my name, there am I with them.' This emphasizes the power of corporate prayer and unity among believers. It's not a magical formula guaranteeing every selfish whim, but rather an assurance that when believers are united in purpose, aligned with God's will (especially regarding serious matters like reconciliation and holiness), their prayers are heard and answered by the Father. The culminating promise, 'For where two or three gather in my name, there am I with them,' is a powerful affirmation of Christ's real and active presence within His church, regardless of its size. This promise undergirds all the preceding instructions, providing the foundation for the church's authority and the efficacy of its prayers and decisions. It assures believers that they do not navigate difficult situations alone; Christ Himself is present, guiding, empowering, and sanctifying His community. This passage reveals God as intimately present, responsive to the unified prayers of His people, and committed to empowering His church to live out His kingdom values on earth, ultimately fostering holiness, unity, and a clear witness to the world.

Scripture

Matthew 18:15-20

Old Testament Connections

Leviticus 19:17 (NIV)
"‘Do not hate your brother in your heart. Rebuke your neighbor frankly so you will not share in their guilt."

Leviticus 19:17 lays the foundational principle of fraternal correction, urging believers to rebuke a sinning neighbor out of love to prevent complicity in their guilt. Matthew 18:15-20 then expands upon this, providing a structured, multi-step process for church discipline that embodies this loving rebuke, aiming for reconciliation and reflecting the authority of Christ within the community.

Deuteronomy 19:15 (NIV)
"One witness is not enough to convict anyone accused of any crime or offense they may have committed. A matter must be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses."

Deuteronomy 19:15 establishes the Old Testament legal principle requiring two or three witnesses to confirm a matter, which Matthew 18:15-20 directly quotes and applies as foundational for discerning truth and ensuring due process in church discipline and reconciliation.

A Moment of Prayer

A prayer inspired by today's topic.

Lord, it's truly disheartening to witness a brother in Christ straying into sin, and I confess my heart often struggles with how to respond. Grant me Your divine wisdom and boundless grace to see them through Your eyes, not with judgment, but with profound compassion and understanding. Guide my words and actions, so I may extend forgiveness and love, gently leading them back to Your truth and light. Soften my own heart, dear Lord, reminding me of Your mercy towards my own failings, and empower me to be an instrument of reconciliation and healing in their life. May Your Holy Spirit move powerfully to bring about their repentance and restoration, for the glory of Your name.

Historical Context

The world behind the Word.

The Gospel of Matthew, from which this passage (18:15-20) is taken, is traditionally attributed to Matthew, also known as Levi, one of Jesus' twelve apostles. However, many modern scholars believe the Gospel was penned by an anonymous Hellenistic Jewish Christian author, likely writing sometime between 80-90 CE. This places its composition after the devastating destruction of the Second Temple in Jerusalem by the Romans in 70 CE, a pivotal event that profoundly reshaped Jewish identity and led to the rise of Rabbinic Judaism. The intended audience for Matthew's Gospel was primarily Jewish Christians, or at least Gentiles who were well-versed in Jewish traditions and the Old Testament. The author's consistent use of Old Testament prophecies to demonstrate Jesus as the Messiah, along with a deep concern for the interpretation and application of the Law, underscores this Jewish-centric focus. The community for whom Matthew wrote was likely grappling with its distinct identity, living in tension with the synagogue, and striving to define its internal communal practices. This passage, in particular, speaks to the practical needs of a nascent community seeking to maintain its moral integrity and resolve internal conflicts. The emphasis on church authority and discipline suggests a more developed community structure than might have existed during Jesus' earthly ministry. The political and social climate of the time was dominated by Roman rule over Judea and Galilee, which brought with it a complex interplay of direct Roman governance, local Jewish autonomy through the Sanhedrin, and various socio-religious factions within Judaism (e.g., Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, Zealots). Roman presence often meant heavy taxation and cultural clashes, leading to widespread social unrest and diverse messianic expectations among the Jewish populace. For the early Christian communities, existing as a sect within Judaism, this environment was fraught with challenges from both Roman authorities and established Jewish leadership. The reference to treating someone as a 'pagan or a tax collector' (Matthew 18:17) starkly illustrates the social boundaries and perceived outcasts within Jewish society, highlighting how the early church was defining its own community standards by contrasting itself with those considered outside the covenant or morally corrupt collaborators with Roman power. The cultural and religious landscape was deeply rooted in Jewish tradition. Matthew presents Jesus as the new Moses, a teacher who interprets and fulfills the Law. The concept of 'binding and loosing' (Matthew 18:18) has direct parallels in rabbinic Judaism, where it referred to the authoritative legal decisions made by rabbis, declaring something permissible or forbidden, or even excommunication. By applying this authority to the nascent church, Matthew underscores the community's divinely sanctioned power to make judgments and maintain order, mirroring the authority of established Jewish courts. The teachings in this passage demonstrate an emphasis on communal responsibility, reconciliation, and the serious nature of sin within the Christian fellowship. While the Gospel is profoundly Jewish in its outlook, the pervasive Hellenistic culture throughout the Roman Empire meant that Greek was the common language of communication and commerce, influencing the very form and dissemination of the Gospel. The geographical setting for the *composition* of Matthew is debated, with Antioch in Syria being a strong candidate due to its large Jewish and Gentile Christian population and its role as a major early Christian center. This would have provided a practical context for needing clear guidelines on community discipline. Alternatively, a Palestinian setting would underscore the direct continuity with Jesus' ministry and the immediate dialogue with Jewish authorities. Regardless of the exact location of composition, the principles laid out in Matthew 18:15-20 were crucial for guiding early Christian communities throughout the Roman world as they sought to live out their faith, resolve disputes, and maintain a distinct identity in the midst of a complex and often hostile external environment. The promise that 'where two or three gather in my name, there am I with them' provided immense encouragement and a sense of divine presence and authority within their fledgling assemblies.

Sermons
2 Found

Bible Time // Matthew 18:15-20

Craig Brown

The Childlikeness of Believers: Confronting Sin (Matthew 18:15-20)

Grace to You